Our History
Keslar Insurance Agency was founded by David Keslar who has decades of experience providing financial solutions in New England. He has experience both as a captive/exclusive insurance agent and as an independent insurance agent, which allows him to understand when and how different types of carriers can be a fit for our customers.
David is joined by his wife, Lisa Keslar, in running the successful business that is Keslar Insurance Agency. Lisa not only works to provide exceptional products and service to customers, but she also handles the community relations, charitable collaboration, and marketing of the organization.
David and Lisa are fortunate to be surrounded by an exceptional team of dedicated professionals who go the extra mile for clients at each and every contact.
Who We Are
Keslar Insurance is an independent insurance agency built on relationships, integrity, and long-term thinking. We believe insurance should be understandable, thoughtfully designed, and aligned with what truly matters to the people and businesses we serve.
We don’t believe in quick quotes or one-size-fits-all solutions. We believe in listening first, educating clearly, and guiding clients toward coverage decisions that make sense for their lives and livelihoods.
Our Purpose
Protecting What Matters Most
Insurance is about more than policies. It’s about peace of mind, confidence, and knowing you’re prepared when the unexpected happens.
Our purpose is simple: to protect what matters most by helping clients understand their risks, their options, and the coverage that best supports their goals.
How We Show Up
At Keslar, how we work matters just as much as what we do.
-
We take the time to understand your situation
-
We explain coverage clearly, without pressure or jargon
-
We recommend what’s right — even if it’s not the cheapest option
-
We do the right thing, even when it’s hard
That commitment guides every interaction, every recommendation, and every decision we make.
OUR APPROACH
What You Can Expect When You Work With Us
We’ve designed our approach to be clear, consistent, and client-focused — so nothing feels rushed, confusing, or reactive.
Our Proven Approach
-
Listen First
We learn what’s driving your decision, what you’re protecting, and what matters most to you. -
Review & Educate
We review your current coverage, identify gaps or risks, and explain your options in plain language. -
Recommend Thoughtfully
We present coverage options from highly rated carriers, focusing on value — not just price. -
Guide the Decision
We answer questions, walk through tradeoffs, and help you choose coverage with confidence. -
Support Long-Term
After binding, we stay with you — handling service needs, claims support, and renewals as your life or business evolves.
Our goal is to make insurance feel manageable, informed, and aligned with your priorities.
THE KESLAR DIFFERENCE
Why Clients Choose Keslar Insurance
Clients work with us because they want more than a transaction — they want a trusted advisor.
What Sets Us Apart
-
Education First
We believe informed clients make better decisions. -
Consistency & Follow-Through
Our team works from shared processes and standards, so your experience doesn’t depend on who answers the phone. -
Integrity Without Compromise
We will always recommend what’s right — even if it costs us business. -
Strong Regional & National Partnerships
We work with highly rated carriers to provide options that balance coverage, service, and cost.
When you work with Keslar, you get clarity, confidence, and a team that stands behind its recommendations.
OUR PROMISE
Our Guarantee
We promise to act in your best interest — always.
That means:
-
Honest recommendations
-
Clear explanations
-
Thoughtful coverage design
-
Support when you need it most
If something doesn’t feel right, we’ll address it. If there’s a better solution, we’ll say so. Our reputation matters, and we protect it the same way we protect our clients.
Keslar Insurance Agency is Proud to Be a Part Of
As Well As
We represent dozens of leading insurance carriers, both national and regional, which allows us to do the insurance shopping for you. Our goal is to provide you exceptional value- which is why we are dedicated to seeking out the best companies that offer the appropriate coverages at a fair price.
As an independent insurance agency, our goal is to assist you in all your insurance needs. We know that it is important to protect the most important things in your life- your family, your possessions, and your business. Over time, your needs will change and we want to be a partner with you through these changes, ensuring you have the right coverages at the right times. We will help you manage and plan for any potential risks.
The employees at Keslar Insurance Agency will work hard to build a trusted relationship with you. Therefore, we focus all our efforts on providing the kind of service and value we’d expect for ourselves and our families. Service is the most important value we offer you; whether it is in response to an insurance claim or a general question.
Meet the Keslar Insurance Agency Team
The employees at Keslar Insurance Agency are all professionals with an innate desire to provide exceptional products and services to our customers. They will work hard to build a trusted relationship with you. As part of that, we focus all our efforts on providing the kind of service and value we’d expect for ourselves and our families. Service is the most important value we offer you; whether it is in response to an insurance claim or a general question.
We look forward to the opportunity to talk to you about your needs and discuss the services that we offer, which include: Home (also called property or hazard), Mobile home, Auto, Life, Umbrella, Renters, Landlord, Boat, Snowmobile, ATV, Commercial Auto, General Liability, Worker’s compensation, and more.
Kendyl Silverwood
Licensed Agent
Shannon Normand
Customer Support Specialist
Linda Marciniszyn
Accounting Operations Specialist
We want you to feel both comfortable and confident in our abilities by acting as your consultant. As professionals, we assess your needs and offer you a variety of insurance products to choose from.
We are always looking for innovative ways to serve you better. For instance, we have great technologies including a full online quoting system as well as an exceptional online customer service center. This allows you to get the information you need quickly, from anywhere, at any time.
We look forward to the opportunity to talk to you about your needs and discuss the services that we offer, which include:
Home (also called property or hazard), Mobile home, Auto, Life, Umbrella, Renters, Landlord, Boat, Snowmobile, ATV, Commercial Auto, General Liability, Worker’s compensation, and more.
Keslar Insurance Agency’s
Awards & Accomplishments
